Top Tenant Retention Tips for Landlords
After working with hundreds of property owners through Hemlane's platform, I have seen firsthand how the right approach to tenant relationships can transform a property management business. The difference between struggling with constant turnover and building a stable profitable portfolio often comes down to how you treat the people living in your properties.
Why Tenant Retention Should Be Your Top Priority
Let me share some numbers that tell the real story. According to MRI Software 2024 analysis the national average retention rate sits at 56% though RealPage Analytics reports that just over 54% of renters in market rate apartments renewed their leases in the year ending October 2024. If you are hitting 60% or higher you are doing better than most.
The Real Cost of Turnover
Research from the Institute of Real Estate Management shows tenant turnover typically costs between $1,000 and $2,500 per unit and that is before you account for lost rent. In competitive markets like Denver these costs can climb to $2,500-$5,000 per turnover event.
Here's what I've observed working with property managers: when you have a vacant unit sitting empty for the current market average of 38 days, you're not just losing rental income. You are also paying for-
- Premium listing services like Zillow and Apartments.com
- Cleaning and repairs beyond normal maintenance
- Administrative time for showings and applications
- Potential rent concessions to attract new tenants quickly
For a property renting at $1,800 per month that 38-day vacancy plus listing costs easily exceeds $2,000 and that is assuming everything goes smoothly.
The Upside of Long-Term Tenants
Beyond avoiding turnover costs keeping good tenants creates predictable cash flow. You can plan property improvements budget for the year ahead and build a reputation that attracts quality applicants through word of mouth referrals.
According to the 2024 NMHC & Grace Hill Renter Preference Survey 87% of residents consider on site amenities crucial in their leasing decisions. But this is what the data does not capture that tenants who feel valued and heard are far more likely to renew regardless of amenity packages.
Creating Effective Communication Channels
One of the most common complaints I hear from tenants is "I cannot reach my landlord when something breaks." In our experience at Hemlane, responsive communication is not just good customer service but it is the foundation of retention.
The Legal Framework for Communication
While being responsive is good business, it is also often legally required. Under the implied warranty of habitability landlords in most states must maintain rental properties in livable condition. This includes responding to maintenance requests that affect health and safety.
State laws vary on response times. For example
- New York's Housing Maintenance Code requires specific timelines for different types of repairs
- Wisconsin's ATCP 134 requires landlords to disclose contact information for management and maintenance
- Texas Property Code outlines reasonable timeframes for addressing tenant requests
Setting Up Your Communication System
Here is what works- establish multiple channels so tenants can reach you however they prefer. At Hemlane our Tenant Portal lets residents submit maintenance requests 24/7 meaning a plumbing emergency at 2 AM gets documented immediately rather than waiting until business hours.
Our repair coordination team handles thousands of requests annually with an average tenant satisfaction rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. The secret is fast and transparent responses. Even if you cannot fix something immediately acknowledging the request within a few hours makes tenants feel heard.
Building Community in Your Properties
Research reported in The Wall Street Journal shows that tenants who make friends in their buildings are significantly more likely to renew their leases. This insight has shaped how many successful property managers approach retention.
Consider organizing:
- Seasonal gatherings- Summer BBQs or holiday parties create natural opportunities for neighbors to connect
- Practical events- Professional networking mixers or food truck visits that add value to the tenants lives
- Casual activities: Movie nights, block parties or team sports that foster ongoing relationships
You do not need a big budget for these initiatives. Even a simple email introducing new tenants to their neighbors or creating a building group chat can spark community connections.
Understanding Your Legal Obligations
Compliance is not optional and understanding your responsibilities protects both you and your tenants while building trust.
Security Deposit Laws Vary by State
Security deposit regulations differ significantly across states. Here are some examples from our research:
New York (General Obligations Law § 7-103 to § 7-108):
- Maximum deposit: One month rent
- Return deadline: 14 days with itemized deductions
- Must be held in interest-bearing account for buildings with 6+ units
Pennsylvania (Landlord and Tenant Act of 1951):
- Maximum: 2 months rent in year one and 1 month thereafter
- Return deadline: 30 days
- Must disclose bank information to tenant
Texas (Property Code Section 92.101-92.110):
- No mandated maximum
- Return deadline: 30 days
- Must provide itemized deductions if withholding any amount
Check your state requirements at your state attorney general website or through resources like Rocket Lawyer's state-by-state guide.
Fair Housing Compliance
The Fair Housing Act (42 U.S.C. 3601 et seq.) prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status or disability. Many states add additional protected classes.
What this means in practice:
- Apply the same screening criteria to every applicant
- Charge the same fees and deposits across the board
- Do not make assumptions about someone's ability to pay based on protected characteristics
- Provide reasonable accommodations for tenants with disabilities
As the Department of Justice notes even unintentional discrimination policies that have a disparate impact on protected classes can violate fair housing law. Document your screening criteria and apply them consistently.
Proactive Maintenance: The Retention Secret Weapon
I cannot stress this enough- regular maintenance and quick responses to repair requests are non-negotiable if you want to retain tenants.
According to facility management research 60% of tenants leave due to poor customer service and communication. When tenants report that the heat is not working or there is a leak they are not just asking for a repair they are asking you to demonstrate that their home and comfort matter.
Creating a Maintenance System
Property managers who excel at retention have structured processes
- Prioritize emergency repairs: No heat in winter, water leaks, electrical hazards need same day or next day attention
- Maintain a reliable contractor list: Having pre-vetted plumbers, electricians and HVAC technicians saves time when issues arise
- Follow up after repairs: Check that the work was completed satisfactorily and the tenant is happy with the resolution
Many property managers use platforms like Hemlane to track maintenance requests, coordinate with contractors and keep tenants updated throughout the repair process. This level of organization prevents requests from falling through the cracks.
Gathering and Acting on Tenant Feedback
One practice that consistently improves retention rates is asking tenants what they think and actually implementing their suggestions.
Designing Your Survey
Consider asking
- How satisfied are you with the maintenance response time?
- What would improve your living experience here?
- Are there any amenities you would like to see added?
- How would you rate your overall satisfaction on a scale of 1 to 10?
- Would you recommend this property to your friends?
The key is keeping surveys short 5 to 7 questions max and making it clear that you value their input. Consider offering a small incentive like a $25 gift card for completed surveys.
Acting on What You Learn
Collecting feedback means nothing if you do not respond to it. When multiple tenants mention the same issue, slow Wi-Fi in common areas, insufficient parking or outdated appliances then those become your priorities.
Even small changes can significantly impact perception. One property manager I worked with added package lockers after survey feedback about missed deliveries. The cost was under $2,000 but tenant satisfaction jumped measurably.
The Personal Touch Makes the Difference
Technology and systems are important but never forget that property management is fundamentally about relationships.
Small gestures create lasting impressions
- Remembering their name and greeting them when you see them
- Sending a welcome basket or card when someone moves in
- Acknowledging birthdays or lease anniversaries
- Being flexible when good tenants face temporary hardships
I have seen property managers waive a late fee when a reliable tenant lost their job then watched that tenant become one of their best advocates staying for years and referring multiple new tenants.
Transparent Policies Build Trust
Confusion creates conflict. When tenants understand your policies and procedures upfront you avoid misunderstandings that can damage relationships.
What to Document Clearly
Your lease and tenant handbook should spell out
- Rent payment methods and due dates
- Late fee policies. Ensure they comply with state law
- Maintenance request procedures
- Guest and occupancy policies
- Pet policies and associated fees
- Renewal process and notice requirements
Provide this documentation when tenants move in and make it accessible online. When questions arise you can point to the policy rather than appearing arbitrary.
Handling Rent Increases Thoughtfully
Recent market data from Denver shows that rent increases significantly impact tenant decisions, with 3.2% year-over-year increases pushing many tenants to seek alternatives.
When rent increases are necessary:
- Give maximum advance notice (follow state requirements, but more notice is better)
- Explain the reasoning (increased property taxes, maintenance costs, market adjustments)
- Keep increases reasonable and in line with the local market
- Consider smallerand more frequent increases rather than large jumps every few years
Some property managers offer renewal incentives, a free month of parking, a small upgrade or a modest discount—to offset increases for valued tenants.
Offering Services and Amenities That Matter
The 2024 NMHC & Grace Hill Renter Preference Survey reveals that modern renters prioritize different amenities based on demographics. 33% of Gen Z renters seek coworking spaces while residents 35 and above value communal areas for social connections.
You do not need expensive renovations to improve tenant satisfaction. Focus on what your specific tenant base values:
- For young professionals: High-speed internet, package management, flexible workspaces
- For families: Safety features, outdoor space, proximity to schools
- For retirees: Accessible design, quiet environment, maintenance-free living
Even small properties can enhance the tenant experience. One landlord I know with a triplex started offering quarterly professional cleaning of common areas and bulk ordering of high-quality air filters for tenants at cost. These modest investments paid off in longer tenancy periods.
Implementing Your Retention Strategy
Start with these immediate actions:
- Audit your communication channels: Can tenants reach you easily? Are you responding within 24 hours?
- Review your maintenance process: Track your average response time and work to improve it
- Check legal compliance: Verify you are following your state security deposit, fair housing and maintenance laws
- Plan one community-building event: Even something simple to test the waters
- Send a tenant satisfaction survey: Learn what matters most to the people living in your properties
Remember, retention is not about grand gestures but about consistently doing the basics well and treating tenants as valued customers rather than just occupants.
Resources for Property Managers
Stay informed about your legal obligations and industry best practices:
At Hemlane, we have built our platform specifically to help property managers like you implement these retention strategies efficiently. Our Tenant Portal, maintenance coordination and automated communication tools free up your time to focus on relationship-building rather than administrative tasks.
The Bottom Line
With the national average retention rate at 56% achieving rates above 60% and ideally closer to 70% positions your property management business for long-term success. Every tenant who renews represents money saved on turnover costs and stability gained for your portfolio.
The strategies outlined here are not theoretical but proven approaches that successful property managers implement daily. Start with one or two changes, measure the impact and build from there. Your future self and your bank account will thank you for prioritizing tenant retention today.
This guide draws on current research, legal resources and real-world experience from property managers across the United States. Laws and best practices evolve so always verify current requirements in your jurisdiction and consider consulting with a real estate attorney for specific legal questions.
Get the Latest in Real Estate & Property Management!
I consent to receiving news, emails, and related marketing communications. I have read and agree with the privacy policy.
